Determinants of bank closures : Do changes of CAMEL variables matter?

Show full item record

Title: Determinants of bank closures : Do changes of CAMEL variables matter?
Author: Mäkinen, Mikko ; Solanko, Laura
Organization: Bank of Finland
Department / Unit: Institute for Economies in Transition (BOFIT)
Series: BOFIT Discussion Papers
Series number: 16/2017
Year of publication: 2017
Publication date: 30.10.2017
Published in: Published in Russian Journal of Money and Finance, 77, 2, 2018, 3–21
Pages: 27
Subject (yso): taseet; indikaattorit; riskit; konkurssi
Keywords: Bofit-kokoelma; Venäjä; pankkitoiminta; likviditeetti
JEL: G01; G21; G32; G34
Other keywords: bank closure; bank failure; Russia; CAMEL indicators
Abstract: This study examines whether changes in CAMEL variables matter in explaining bank closure. Using a unique set of monthly bank-specific balance sheet data from Russia, we estimate determinants of bank license withdrawals during 2013m7-2017m7. We make two key findings. First, changes in CAMEL indicators are always significantly correlated with probability of bank closure, and the magnitude of parameter estimates decreases with the lag length. Second, while the one-month lagged levels of capital, earnings, and liquidity are significantly associated with the probability of bank closure in the subsequent month, the level of liquidity is the only significant indicator for longer lags. Our key contribution that changes in CAMEL variables matter more than levels is robust to various robustness checks.
Rights: https://helda.helsinki.fi/bof/copyright


Files in this item

Total number of downloads: Loading...

Files Size Format View
dp1617.pdf 470.8Kb PDF View/Open

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show full item record