Hokkanen, Mirja
(Finnish Food Authority, 2021)
Finnish Food Authority Research Reports 2/2021
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) contamination in food poses a potential
risk to human health. PAHs are formed primarily as a result of incomplete
combustion of organic material and can enter the food chain either from the
environment or from food manufacturing processes such as smoking, roasting,
drying and grilling. As some of them are known to cause cancer, it is important to
reduce the PAH levels in foods as low as is reasonably achievable. The European
Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has evaluated the sum of PAH4 compounds
(=benzo[a]pyrene (BaP), benz[a]anthracene (BaA), chrysene (CHR) and benzo[b]
fuoranthene (BbF)) to serve as a suitable indicator of both the occurrence and
toxicity of the PAHs.
The primary purpose of this dissertation study was to assess for the frst time
Finnish children’s potential health risk caused by dietary exposure to PAH4. In
order to complete this task, the applied analytical method must be appropriately
validated to be able to produce precise occurrence data. In this study, the gas
chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry method was successfully validated
according to legislative requirements and the occurrence of PAH4 in a wide range
of food groups (fsh, meat, fat and oil, bread, cereal and muesli) was determined.
Generally, the concentrations of PAH4 in foods were low and below the prevailing
maximum levels. That being said, in smoked fsh and meat products, the variation
of the detected PAH4 levels was high, up to 200 µg/kg in smoked ham. It appeared
that the smoking process was either controlled or not, and the science-based
guidance is required to prevent and reduce contamination of PAHs. Therefore, our
goal was to investigate the critical smoking factors that afect the PAH4 formation
in fsh and meat products in order to provide tools for manufacturers to produce
safer smoked products, thereby decreasing human dietary exposure and adverse
health efects. Based on our results, indirect smoking, smoking in less than fve
hours, optimised smoke generation temperature between 400 and 600 °C and
distance more than fve metres between the food and the smoke source led to
reduced PAH4 levels in smoked fsh and meat products.
This study aimed to gain a better understanding of the potential mutagenicity
of the processed foods, and therefore selected fsh and meat products were tested
by the Ames test in Salmonella TA 100 and TA 98 strains with or without metabolic
activation. The outcome was further compared to the chemical PAH4 analyses.
The statistically signifcant mutagenic response was observed in all three lots
of smoked Baltic herring, which also indicated higher PAH4 concentrations
than other samples. By contrast, the tested meat products were not mutagenic
and the corresponding individual PAH4 concentrations were, for the most part,
undetectable. Despite the challenges in food mutagenicity testing, our results
provided more information on the potential mutagenic activity of various foods.
Specifcally, based on our fndings, a combination of both biological assays and
chemical analyses can improve the interpretation of the fndings regarding
mutagenicity.
Lastly, in reference to our primary purpose of considering potential safety
concerns of PAH4 in food, Finnish children’s dietary exposure to PAH4 was
evaluated by combining the acquired occurrence and food consumption data.
Utilising that data, a margin of exposure (MOE) was calculated in order to be
used to provide relative indication of the level of health concern and support
prioritisation of possible risk management actions. Our results demonstrated
that bread, smoked ham, fat and oil and sausage contributed the most to BaP
and PAH4 exposure. Even though the mean PAH4 levels in bread were below
the limit of detection, its consumption volumes are high, which explains the
contribution. Children’s total mean dietary exposure was estimated to BaP 1,500
pg/kg bw/day and to PAH4 8,100 pg/kg bw/day. The total margins of exposure
(MOEs) for children were 482,000 for BaP and 42,000 for PAH4. Furthermore,
the calculated MOEs for highly exposed children were also above the reference
value 10,000, which caused them to be considered of low concern. Taking into
account uncertainties and limitations, this study indicated no health risk to
Finnish children aged three to six years.