Analogies in IP: Moral Rights

Show full item record



Simon , D 2019 , ' Analogies in IP: Moral Rights ' , Yale Journal of Law & Technology , vol. 21 , 337 , pp. 337-385 .

Title: Analogies in IP: Moral Rights
Author: Simon, David
Contributor: Hanken School of Economics, Commercial Law, Helsinki
Belongs to series: Yale Journal of Law & Technology
Abstract: This Article critically examines the analogies scholars use to explain the special relation between the author and her work that copyright law protects under the doctrine of moral rights. The goal of this Article is to determine “when to drop the analogy and get on with developing the” content of the relation between the author and the work.” Upon examination, that moment approaches rather quickly: none of these analogies provide any helpful framework for understanding the purported relation. At worst, they are misleading rhetorical devices used to gain support for moral rights. At best, these analogies are first attempts at describing the relation between author and her work. So I assume that analogies are valuable as starting points for thinking about the relation between the author and her work, rather than explaining the nature of the relation. Even when viewed this way, however, the analogies raise more questions than they purport to answer. Because the analogies discussed do not explain the author-work relation, scholars must look elsewhere for arguments to support moral rights.
Date: 2019
Subject: 513 Law
1 - Open access publication channel
1 - Self archived
1- Minst en av författarna har en utländsk affiliation
1- Publicerad utomlands
0- Ingen affiliation med ett företag
AoHP: Digitisation and sustainability in intellectual property

Files in this item

Total number of downloads: Loading...

Files Size Format View
21_yale_j.l._tech._337_0.pdf 719.1Kb PDF View/Open

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show full item record